Q11. Discuss the merits and demerits of the four ‘Labour Codes’ in the context of labour market reforms in India. What has been the progress so far in these regards?

Approach

‍

Introduction

The four Labour Codes—Code on Wages, Industrial Relations Code, Social Security Code, and Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions Code—represent a major overhaul of India's outdated labour laws. These reforms aim to simplify the legal framework, improve ease of doing business, and provide enhanced protection for workers. The journey toward labour reforms has been driven by the need to balance economic growth with labour rights.

Body

Merits:

  • Simplification and Consolidation: The Labour Codes consolidate 29 existing labour laws into four simplified codes, making compliance easier and reducing bureaucratic hurdles for businesses.
  • Uniformity in Wages: The wage uniformity is expected to reduce wage discrimination and ensure a living wage for workers, which is especially important in the informal and unorganized sectors.
  • Expanded Social Security: The Social Security Code extends benefits such as provident fund, insurance, and gratuity to all workers, including gig and platform workers, who were previously excluded from formal social protection systems.
  • Improved Safety Standards: The Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions Code mandates better safety standards, working conditions, and welfare measures, ensuring that workers' health and safety are protected, particularly in high risk industries such as construction and manufacturing.
  • Streamlined Dispute Resolution: The Industrial Relations Code simplifies the process of resolving industrial disputes, with provisions that aim to promote industrial harmony. It introduces new mechanisms, including Industrial Tribunals, which could expedite dispute settlements and reduce disruptions.

Demerits:

  • Impact on the Unorganised Sector: Although the codes aim to cover unorganised workers, the effectiveness of implementation mechanisms remains questionable. There is concern that many workers in this sector may not fully benefit due to poor enforcement and lack of awareness.
  • Greater Employer Leverage: The Industrial Relations Code allows for easier retrenchment, layoffs, and closure of establishments by reducing thresholds for approvals. This could potentially lead to job insecurity and make it easier for employers to terminate workers.
  • Dilution of Labour Rights: Critics argue that the stricter conditions for strikes, including longer notice periods and limitations on collective action, dilute existing labour rights.
  • Ambiguities in Key Definitions: Terms like "wages" and "workers" are ambiguously defined, leading to possible misinterpretations and inconsistencies in enforcement, which could be exploited by employers, resulting in worker exploitation.
  • Implementation Challenges: With labour being a concurrent subject, the success of these codes largely depends on state-level rulemaking and enforcement. This delay poses challenges to realizing the intended reforms.

Progress So Far:

  • The Labour Codes were passed by Parliament in 2019 and 2020. However, their implementation has been delayed due to the need for states to frame corresponding rules. Some states have initiated this process, but a nationwide rollout is still pending. 
  • The central government has conducted consultations with stakeholders and launched awareness programs to ensure a smoother transition to the new system. 
  • Despite these efforts, the reforms' effectiveness will largely depend on the timely and uniform implementation of the codes across states.

Conclusion

The Labour Codes represent a significant step toward modernizing India's labor laws by simplifying compliance, enhancing social security, and improving workplace safety. However, effective implementation and addressing the concerns of the unorganized sector will be critical to ensuring that these reforms benefit all stakeholders. Continuous engagement with labor unions, employers, and state governments will be necessary to refine the codes and ensure they meet the diverse needs of India’s labor market.

‍

Instant Mains Evaluation with SuperKalam

✅ Now that you have gone through the model answer, try practicing and writing it in your own words and evaluate it instantly with SuperKalam here - Evaluate Mains Answer instantly

‍

✅ Download Model Answer PDF for complete UPSC Mains 2024 GS3 Paper with analysis here - Download GS3 Model Answers

Read more blogs